Probably Stolen beginner guide: a two-week plan for your first shop
Probably Stolen is a shopkeeping game where rent keeps rising and you win by buying your store from the landlord. This page turns what several guides say into one plan you can follow in your first two weeks. Checked 2026-11-13 against the latest patch we know of, the 100-Rev13 hotfix of November 8, 2026.
How this guide was made
We have not played the game ourselves, so this is not a playtest report. We read the official Steam page and patch posts and four community guides, and we only treat a tip as solid when at least two of them agree or the developer says it. Anything that appears in one source only is labelled as single-source below, so you know to test it yourself. Guide authors had access to the game and we credit them in the source list.
What you are trying to do
According to the Steam page, you run a shop on a divided space station, deal in goods of doubtful origin and try to earn enough to buy out the store before the rent catches up with you. Every plan below therefore serves one number: the credits you will have on the next rent date.
Step 1: pick a beginner-friendly start
The developer describes the Apprentice start as a generalist start that is best for beginners, and one community guide also recommends it for a first run. Rock Bottom is the opposite: you start with nothing at maximum difficulty. The official list has nine scenarios in version 1.0 (see our gameplay page). One of the guides we read names only four of them, so use the in-game list, not a guide's list. The patch notes name four difficulty options: Cozy, Normal, Hard and Challenge. The developer advises against the Sentinel Collapse Disorder mode on a first run.
Step 2: days 1 to 3, make your first credits
- Open the shutter and read each customer's request before you answer. Note what they want to buy or sell and how much they can afford.
- Buy cheap food, drinks and household goods from sellers and resell them to buyers whose budget and categories match. Three guides recommend this as the first source of profit.
- Look at the lease and the next collection date on day 1, and treat that amount as untouchable. Two guides give this same advice.
- Do not stock every category. Pick one, usually food, until you have sold through it and have money to branch out.
- Before you open the shutter each day, set the display case. One guide notes that anything added after the shop opens only takes effect the next day.
Step 3: days 4 to 14, add income that is not the counter
- Appraisals: once an appraisal contact appears, valuing items correctly pays a fee without you buying stock. Two guides name this as a steady side income.
- Production: turning cheap inputs into more valuable goods, such as water, wine or metal ingots, is the mid-game route two guides both describe. Buy one machine that supports one business, not every machine you can afford.
- Bounties: reporting wanted criminals pays rewards, but your decisions have consequences, so only report when you are sure of the match.
- Night trips: scavenging at night can give cheap stock, but you open later the next morning and lose a customer. Go only with a specific goal, bring a bag with room and a bandage.
What the guides agree on
| Tip | Agreed by | How we use it |
|---|---|---|
| Specialise in one goods category early | TheGamer, KeenGamer, Output Lag | Start with food, then expand once you have cash |
| Keep the rent payment aside | KeenGamer, Output Lag | Check the lease first thing on day 1 |
| Set the display case before opening | TheGamer, Output Lag | Part of the evening routine, not the morning |
| Night scavenging costs a morning customer | TheGamer, KeenGamer, Output Lag | Go out only for a named item |
| Bargaining affects reputation as well as price | TheGamer, Probably Stolen Codex | Use it sparingly, mostly to build faction goodwill |
| Check the daily newspaper and market events | TheGamer, Probably Stolen Codex | Hold stock for items in short supply |
| Appraisals add income without buying stock | Output Lag, Probably Stolen Codex | Take the contact when it appears |
| Production chains scale better than reselling alone | Output Lag, Probably Stolen Codex | One machine, one business, then expand |
Where sources differ or only one source says it
These details come from a single guide, or the guides do not match, so treat them as claims to test in your own save.
| Claim | Source | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Bargaining unlocks after day 8 | TheGamer | Probably Stolen Codex says only that it unlocks once the Mentor teaches it |
| Retail markup is 20% or 15% depending on the setting | Probably Stolen Codex | Not confirmed by the other guides |
| Wholesale piles come 15 to 33% below base value | Probably Stolen Codex | Not confirmed by the other guides |
| Reporting nine criminals is worth 3,600 credits in total | Probably Stolen Codex | Reward totals may change with updates |
| Georgio can join a scavenging run for 50 credits and prevent injury | TheGamer | Not confirmed by the other guides |
| Number of starting scenarios | KeenGamer lists four | The developer lists nine |
A checklist for every customer
This is our own summary of the advice above, not a quote from any guide.
- What does this customer want, and is it in a category I hold or want to hold?
- Can they afford it? A valuable item does not sell to a buyer without the budget.
- Is the item genuine, damaged or counterfeit? Inspect before paying a genuine price.
- Is my price near the market price, and is anything in the newspaper pushing it up or down?
- After this trade, will I still be able to cover the next rent date?
Common first-week mistakes
- Buying every category and ending up with stock nobody wants.
- Spending the rent reserve on machines or upgrades.
- Paying the price of a genuine item for a counterfeit.
- Demanding large discounts or markups and losing reputation.
- Leaving the shop every night with no target.
Check the patch notes before trusting numbers
Several guides were written in the first days after launch. The developer rebalanced water-related machine and item prices on launch day (patch 1.0.0.2), and later shipped cumulative updates up to 1.0.0.12 and a hotfix on November 8. Prices and profit figures in any guide may be out of date. See our Probably Stolen news page for the full list of patches.
Sources
- Official: Probably Stolen on Steam
- Official: Water Balance & Hotfix 1.0.0.2 (Oct 28, 2026)
- Official: Cumulative Update 1.0.0.12 (Nov 6, 2026)
- Official: 100-Rev13 Hotfix (Nov 8, 2026)
- Community: TheGamer, Beginner Tips And Tricks For Probably Stolen
- Community: KeenGamer, Probably Stolen Complete Walkthrough & Beginner Tips
- Community: Output Lag, How to Make Money and Start From $0
- Community: Probably Stolen Codex, How to Make Money Fast
Community guides are listed so you can read the originals. We rewrite what several of them agree on in our own structure and do not copy their text, tables or screenshots.